Israel-Palestinian conflict writ large on road signs
Published: 17th Aug 2011 01:30:52
The increasingly heated dispute over place names in Israel underlies a much greater political struggle, the BBC's Yolande Knell explains from Jerusalem.
"Where are you going?" asked the friendly, but slightly over-familiar, Jewish-Israeli boy sitting next to me on the plane from London.
"I work in Jerusalem," I replied.
His smile instantly turned to a scowl. "It's not Jerusalem," he said. "It's Yerushalayim".
"That's in Hebrew, but in English we say Jerusalem," I protested and I was about to add - somewhat mischievously - that my Palestinian friends refer to it as "al-Quds" - the Arabic name for the city.
But at that point, the boy's little sister spilled orange juice over his lap. Our conversation was cut short.
Land may be at the heart of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict but every day the struggle to control the historical narrative is played out most tangibly in language.
Place names are the most obvious example.
If some prominent politicians on the Israeli right have their way, then in future the road signs here will only point to "Yerushalayim".
A proposal to have all signs displaying just the transliterations of Hebrew names of cities and towns is being considered by a new ministerial committee.
There is strong opposition among Israel's population of more than one million Arab-Israelis but also from members of the Government Names Committee.
These independent experts have been responsible for selecting place names since the 1950s - not long after the creation of the state of Israel. They argue that changing the system will confuse tourists.
But others believe that complete Judaisation of the map is long overdue.
At 32, Tzipi Hotovely is the youngest member of the Israeli parliament. A well-qualified lawyer and religious right-winger, she is also seen as the ideological voice and rising star of the prime minister's Likud party.
She finds it unacceptable that although Hebrew names were given to Jerusalem neighbourhoods years ago, many Arabic ones have stuck.
For example, while the names of streets around the prime minister's residence read like an A to Z of Zionism, the upscale area itself is still called by its original Arabic name "Talbiya" - instead of "Komemiyut" or "Independence" - its given Hebrew name.
The same goes for Bakah and Malha, alias Geulim and Manahat.
Ms Hotovely has introduced a bill that would require different neighbourhoods to be identified by their Hebrew names only - on signposts, official documents and in state media.
She sees it as part of the wider battle for Jerusalem - which both Israelis and Palestinians claim as their capital. Names are "very powerful symbols" she tells me.
The biggest problems arise in East Jerusalem - which was occupied by Israel in 1967 and is still a mainly Arab area - although Jewish settlers are fast moving in, taking over Palestinian homes.
Ms Hotovely wants the names of its quarters changed too.
"Most places in the east side of Jerusalem are part of our biblical heritage. It is very important to know the cultural history. The city was founded by David the King and many neighbourhoods are originally Jewish neighbourhoods," she says.
For Huda Imam, a well-known, energetic Palestinian activist born in the Sheikh Jarrah area of East Jerusalem, such pronouncements are worrying.
Already she says she sees more and more signs for Shimon HaTzedik instead of Sheikh Jarrah.
The Hebrew name indicates the tomb is thought to belong to an ancient Jewish priest while the Arabic derives from the surgeon of the 12th Century Muslim leader, Saladin.
Huda points out the landmarks that suggest her neighbourhood's vibrant Arab history.
Many recent ones are tinged with a sense of loss like the Hind al-Husseini orphan school, Orient House, once the Jerusalem headquarters for Palestinian officials, and the Shepherd Hotel, demolished in January.
On the hillside there is also the green-shuttered house that Huda's own father built and which, she says, the Israeli authorities confiscated and later sold.
She feels that Israel is abandoning hopes of peaceful co-existence.
"I don't want to say they're succeeding because I'm still here," she adds. "But it's destroying any trust. They're erasing all traces of Palestinian identity."
There are many Palestinians and some Jewish Israelis trying to stop that from happening.
On Fridays, they organise noisy demonstrations on the streets in Sheikh Jarrah. Often there are scuffles with settlers, both sides asserting their competing claims.
The continuing fight for the rights to Jerusalem, and all the holy land, takes many forms.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2011. Israel-Palestinian conflict writ large on road signs. [Online] (Updated 17 Aug 2011)
Available at: http://www.manchesterwired.co.uk/news.php/178345-Israel-Palestinian-conflict-writ-large-on-road-signs [Accessed 14th June 2013]
At 06:19:37 in OtherMurdered PC Fiona Bone was "a lovely, bubbly person" who was always looking for her next challenge, according to her father, Paul....
At 06:18:12 in OtherThe father of murdered PC Nicola Hughes said once his daughter had decided to become a police officer, he knew she would never change her mi...
At 06:05:15 in OtherThe lives of police and public were risked by Dale Cregan's daily trip from jail to court, Greater Manchester's Police and Crime C...
At 05:43:47 in HeadlinesThe ousting of Stephen Hester from the Royal Bank of Scotland has provoked some forthright comment....
At 05:05:32 in OtherDale Cregan's killings of David Short and PCs Nicola Hughes and Fiona Bone are the first time hand grenades have been used as murder we...
At 04:04:38 in HeadlinesIt's a problem that gets on lots of people's nerves - the scourge of dog owners who don't clear up after their pets. So, what...
At 00:40:14 in OtherCouncil leaders representing 11 local authorities have sent a letter to the Chancellor expressing concern over potential cuts to museums in ...
At 19:32:36 in OtherDale Cregan will spend the rest of his life in jail for four murders, including those of two police officers in Greater Manchester....
At 18:30:53 in OtherThe driver of a minibus carrying a hen party which was involved in a fatal collision on the M62 has been arrested....
At 17:20:27 in OtherMoors Murderer Ian Brady wants to be allowed to die....
News In Other Categories
The US has said it will provide grants to help improve safety standards in Bangladesh garment factories....
A new report indicates that a class of pesticides linked to the deaths of bees may be harming other wildlife species. ...
The Who are back on stage in the UK touring a full-length performance of their classic 70s album, Quadrophenia. Its story belongs to a very ...
In Cardiff Bay there is a wide, tree-lined street that is closed to traffic and runs between the Welsh assembly building and the Wales Mille...
A 49-year-old woman is in a critical condition after she was hit by a lorry near Peterhead....
David Cameron is to offer a £1m payment to anyone who can "identify and solve the biggest problem of our time"....