Are government U-turns really a 'sign of strength'?
Published: 21st Jun 2011 16:16:07
Another day, another government U-turn. Or should that be "climb-down"? Or "rethink"?
Or, perhaps, as David Cameron would have it, a well-thought-out response to the legitimate concerns of the public and experts in the field?
The prime minister has hit on a novel formula, showcased again on Tuesday in his announcement on prison sentencing, for dealing with accusations he has committed that most heinous of political crimes.
Rather than desperately trying to pretend it was something he had intended to do all along and the changes were all in the small print of the bill anyway, he says the U-turn is a "sign of strength".
He has yet to cross the Rubicon entirely and proudly reclaim the phrase for politicians everywhere.
We are still a long way from a minister being able to stand up in the House of Commons and announce their latest policy U-turn.
Indeed, government ministers and spin doctors still spend a large part of their working week denying policy rethinks qualify as U-turns.
Justice Secretary Ken Clarke was the latest minister to go down this route, when he was doorstepped by journalists outside his London home on Tuesday morning.
Mr Cameron may feel he has little to choice but to try to turn a negative - the perception the government is floundering - into what feels like a positive.
Ken Clarke: "It's not another U-turn, it's a perfectly balanced package of radical reforms"
Only a government firing on all cylinders, he says, would have the self-confidence to listen to criticism, pause, reflect and come back with an improved set of proposals.
And he is "proud" to lead a listening government.
If this is the case, this must be one of the most self-confident and responsive governments in history.
Recent months have seen alleged U-turns on everything from school sports, privatisation of forests, the NHS, weekly bin collections and now prison sentencing.
With the exception of the revamp of planned changes to the NHS in England - which saw a major piece of legislation stopped in its tracks and sent back a few squares on the legislative grid - these are all middle-ranking issues.
And the coalition has not done the one U-turn its critics say would really matter - on the economy.
But this has not stopped Labour leader Ed Miliband accusing Mr Cameron and his ministers of failing to think policies through before springing them on the world.
Others say Mr Cameron has taken an overly "hands off" approach to government, allowing his ministers too much freedom to come up with policy ideas.
There is certainly a recognisable pattern to the coalition's alleged U-turns.
They tend to begin with a minister stumbling into a storm of tabloid criticism about some proposal or other and end with Mr Cameron - in full listening mode - taking personal charge of the policy.
But do the public actually care?
Mr Cameron's polling may be telling him voters are not particularly bothered if the government does a U-turn as long as it gets the policy right in the end.
And they do not want a prime minister in the Margaret Thatcher mould, ploughing on seemingly impervious to criticism.
In fact, it was Lady Thatcher who is probably more responsible than anyone for cementing the term "U-turn" in the British political lexicon.
The term took off in the early 1970s, when then Prime Minister Ted Heath had to dump his entire market-based economic policy in the face of soaring inflation and rampant industrial action.
Lady Thatcher and her supporters on the monetarist wing of the Conservative Party never forgave him.
She took her revenge a few years later when, faced with a similarly desperate set of economic circumstances, she famously told the 1980 Tory party conference: "You turn if you want to. The lady's not for turning".
It made for a great headline.
And, as Mr Cameron is discovering, more than 30 years later the media's love affair with the phrase shows no sign of fading.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2011. Are government U-turns really a 'sign of strength'?. [Online] (Updated 21 Jun 2011)
Available at: http://www.manchesterwired.co.uk/news.php/164006-Are-government-U-turns-really-a-sign-of-strength [Accessed 22nd May 2013]
At 18:37:46 in OtherUp to 20 people are to lose their jobs at Britvic in Belfast, after the soft drinks company announced it was to close its factory....
At 15:16:41 in OtherBritvic is to close its factory in Chelmsford, the city where the company was founded in the 19th Century, as part of plans to cut hundreds ...
At 14:29:37 in OtherA man who tried to smuggle more than 700 rare and endangered corals and clams into the UK has been jailed....
At 13:49:32 in OtherHow much are the police and crime commissioners costing you? ...
At 13:38:37 in OtherTwo nuns have been cleared of assaulting girls in their care at an approved school in Renfrewshire....
At 13:32:08 in OtherA witness for the prosecution in the Norman Moffatt murder trial has admitted she was addicted to prescription drugs when she said the accus...
At 13:20:32 in OtherTwo men have admitted their involvement in stealing jewellery and watches worth £730,000 in a heist in Edinburgh....
At 12:07:35 in OtherA proposal for a free school staffed by former armed forces personnel has been approved....
At 11:50:44 in OtherPolice killer Dale Cregan has admitted the murders of a father and son in Greater Manchester....
At 10:47:01 in OtherA rare first edition of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, with annotations and drawings by author JK Rowling, has sold for a re...
News In Other Categories
With the doors to its brand new £1million training centre officially open, one of the UK's leading apprentice training providers, Bristol ba...
The funeral of Olympic sailing champion Andrew Simpson will be held in his home town, the Royal Yachting Association has confirmed....
An inflated hedgehog has been saved from "rupturing" by vets who pricked it with a needle....
An international human-rights training centre to teach digital skills to activists and protesters has opened in the Italian city of Florence...
Fast broadband is being rolled out in Surrey after EU competition commissioners approved the state-funded scheme....
We all have nearly 200 different types of fungi colonising our feet, scientists have discovered....