Yaseen Ali Ege murder: Mother 'forced to make admissions'
Published: 12th Jun 2012 19:30:00
A mother accused of killing her seven-year-old son was threatened into making admissions to police, a jury has heard.
Peter Murphy QC, for Sara Ege, said in his closing speech there was no dispute about her son's injuries, but they were inflicted by her husband, Yousuf Ege.
Starting his closing speech at Cardiff Crown Court, Peter Birkitt QC, for Mr Ege, said her confession was compelling
Mrs Ege denies murdering Yaseen. Mr Ege denies causing his death by failing to protect him. The case continues.
The court has heard that the beatings were so brutal that Yaseen died from his injuries. His body was burned to destroy the evidence.
Mrs Ege is accused of making detailed confessions to police about the death in Cardiff over a number of days, and that she was driven by a desire for Yaseen to memorise the Koran.
But Mr Murphy told the court Mrs Ege had been threatened into making admissions.
She (Mrs Ege) was threatened and intimidated into making admissions to police”
He said the defendant's brother-in-law had called the police and claimed that Mrs Ege had told him Yaseen had fainted, had soiled himself and that she had cleaned him up.
Mr Murphy said she thought the boy had died and so set fire to his body.
Mrs Ege's brother-in-law said he had a voice recorder to show police, but it did not have a recording on it, the court heard.
"Why was there a recording device?" said Mr Murphy.
He said Mrs Ege believed there was a recording of the conversation and she thought she had no choice but to go through with the forced confession.
"She (Mrs Ege) was threatened and intimidated into making admissions to police, he said.
Mr Murphy said she only later found the strength to tell the truth, and that her account came out in bits.
He also told jurors that Mrs Ege was the subject of "sustained and ongoing abuse".
Mr Murphy listed a catalogue of medical visits over more than seven years, and mentioned medical notes where doctors noted her history of domestic violence.
She was unburdening herself of a terrible secret”
He claimed it was Mr Ege who put pressure on his son to memorise the Koran having arranged lessons for him with an Imam, who the boy's mother had never met.
The barrister said there was no dispute about Yaseen's injuries, but said it was Mr Ege who inflicted them.
Starting his closing speech, Mr Birkitt for Mr Ege said Mrs Ege's confession was most compelling.
"Could there have been a more compelling confession ever?" he said.
Mr Birkitt described her confession as an "outpouring of someone who had a terrible sense of guilt. She was unburdening herself of a terrible secret."
Mr Birkitt will finish his closing speech on Wednesday.
The prosecution said on the day Yaseen died he suffered three severe blows to his abdomen, and there were other blows to his body.
The death of the couple's son at home in Pontcanna, Cardiff, was treated as a tragic accident when it happened in July 2010.
The trial continues.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Yaseen Ali Ege murder: Mother 'forced to make admissions'. [Online] (Updated 12 Jun 2012)
Available at: http://www.manchesterwired.co.uk/news.php/1434161-Yaseen-Ali-Ege-murder-Mother-forced-to-make-admissions [Accessed 16th May 2013]
At 13:29:23 in OtherThe £3,000 Orwell Book Prize for political writing has been won by AT Williams for his book A Very British Killing: The Death of Baha Mousa....
At 13:25:39 in OtherA £70m biomass incinerator will be built in Greater Manchester despite residents' health fears....
At 13:25:11 in OtherMore than 230 coal jobs have been saved after an energy and waste services group bought parts of collapsed surface mining firm Aardvark (TMC...
At 11:30:09 in OtherA 14-year-old youth has been arrested in Bradford on suspicion of raping a six year-old boy....
At 07:54:41 in OtherA woman who was washed downstream after falling into a river in Greater Manchester has been rescued by the emergency services....
At 07:24:40 in OtherTwelve people have been arrested after raids in Greater Manchester by officers investigating a £3.8m internet-based drugs ring....
At 06:40:10 in OtherTo many, the picture postcard city of Oxford is all about its universities, ancient cobbled streets and dreaming spires....
At 04:26:13 in OtherTougher laws to tackle the threat of dangerous dogs and irresponsible owners do not go far enough, MPs have said....
At 04:01:17 in OtherTV classic Rising Damp is the latest sitcom to be resurrected on stage, following the likes of Yes, Prime Minister and Steptoe & Son....
At 01:28:34 in OtherAt the beginning of 1942 anything of the scale or ambition of the Dambusters raid probably seemed to RAF Bomber Command like a fantasy....
News In Other Categories
A $15m computer that uses "quantum physics" effects to boost its speed is to be installed at a Nasa facility....
A tweet by Sally Bercow pointed the "finger of blame" at Tory peer Lord McAlpine in the wake of a report which saw him wrongly lin...
British hackers who were behind a series of high profile cyber attacks in 2011 have been sentenced....
A leading South African university says it will make Zulu language classes compulsory for all first-year students from next year. ...
Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) is to cut a further 1,400 jobs from its retail banking head office over the next two years....
Police officers may have been lured to a bogus burglary in Dunmurry to be attacked, the PSNI has said....