Head teachers attack chief inspector's 'culture of fear'
Published: 6th May 2012 03:55:35
Head teachers are accusing the chief inspector of schools in England of creating a "culture of fear" in England's schools.
The National Association of Head Teachers says it expected more from Sir Michael Wilshaw, a former head himself.
The NAHT will debate a motion deploring Sir Michael's "negative rhetoric" and promising to "pursue whatever action it deems appropriate" to defend heads.
Ofsted said the intention was to work closely with good heads.
On Saturday delegates put forward a late motion for discussion which called for a vote of no confidence in the chief inspector.
However, after debate, the NAHT decided the wording of it was too strong and amounted to the same sort of bullying rhetoric they were criticising.
We are saddened by Sir Michael, especially as he was a head once”
Overnight, the association drew up a new motion which will be put before members on Sunday morning.
It says: "This conference s both saddened and angered by the approach taken by the current HMIC (Her Majesty's chief inspector).
"We deplore his negative rhetoric which is creating a culture of fear in schools.
"We would have expected him, as a former fellow school leader, to understand that to get the best out of children and staff in schools, we need to both challenge and support.
"We call on national executive to pursue whatever action it deems appropriate to defend our profession."
The motion represents a further straining of relationships between the NAHT and Ofsted, coming just days after the association raised concerns about the quality and impartiality of school inspections.
A poll of more than 2,000 school leaders, conducted by the union, found almost half (45.3%) believed Ofsted made no contribution to, or actively prevented, standards being raised.
Nine out of 10 (89.9%) were either unhappy or very unhappy about the tone and content of recent announcements by the watchdog.
Ofsted has recently announced plans - currently out for consultation - to introduce no-notice inspections for all schools and to scrap the "satisfactory" rating and replace it with "requires improvement".
Vice-president of the NAHT Bernadette Hunter said Ofsted was putting an "intolerable amount of stress" on heads.
Ms Hunter, a primary school head teacher in Staffordshire, said the "horrible rhetoric" from the schools watchdog was putting people off becoming head teachers.
An Ofsted spokeswoman said: "Ofsted has been listening to the views of head teachers, teacher and parents about its proposed changes to school inspections and will announce the results of its consultation at the end of the month.
"The intention is to work closely with good heads as they drive improvement in their schools."
The debate comes despite Education Secretary Michael Gove signalling a u-turn over Sir Michael's plans for no-notice inspections of schools from September.
Addressing the conference on Saturday morning, Mr Gove said the proposals were likely to be dropped.
The plans, announced by Sir Michael in January, caused anger among head teachers, who currently receive 48 hours' notice.
The NAHT welcomed Mr Gove's speech, saying heads had a right to make sure they were on site for inspections.
Sir Michael took up his post in January. He was previously executive head of Mossbourne Academy in Hackney, east London.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Head teachers attack chief inspector's 'culture of fear'. [Online] (Updated 06 May 2012)
Available at: http://www.manchesterwired.co.uk/news.php/1426792-Head-teachers-attack-chief-inspectors-culture-of-fear [Accessed 17th May 2013]
At 07:22:30 in HeadlinesWhat becomes of the broken-hearted? Often, they turn to music. Charles Nevin ponders whether the remedy is best found in cheery tunes or soo...
At 03:22:07 in OtherGraduates on a new fast-track scheme for trainee social workers will help manage caseloads after just five weeks of intensive initial traini...
At 02:49:29 in OtherTime-lapse imaging which takes thousands of pictures of developing embryos can boost the success rate of IVF, according to British research....
At 23:52:51 in BusinessPolice are investigating a frightening new variation of card fraud, which tricks people into handing over all their credit and debit cards o...
At 20:05:39 in OtherProposals to tighten the law governing dangerous dogs will not prevent further tragedies like the death of 14-year-old Jade Anderson, an MP ...
At 19:49:09 in OtherThree hundred new jobs are being created at a Greater Manchester manufacturing firm. ...
At 13:29:23 in OtherThe £3,000 Orwell Book Prize for political writing has been won by AT Williams for his book A Very British Killing: The Death of Baha Mousa....
At 13:25:39 in OtherA £70m biomass incinerator will be built in Greater Manchester despite residents' health fears....
At 13:25:11 in OtherMore than 230 coal jobs have been saved after an energy and waste services group bought parts of collapsed surface mining firm Aardvark (TMC...
At 11:30:09 in OtherA 14-year-old youth has been arrested in Bradford on suspicion of raping a six year-old boy....
News In Other Categories
Fewer young people are still learning after the age of 17 in the UK, a survey suggests....
Fire and rescue services in England need to be "transformed" to become more efficient and effective, a government-commissioned rev...
Time-lapse imaging which takes thousands of pictures of developing embryos can boost the success rate of IVF, according to British research....
Global Energy Group plans to invest £37m upgrading the South Quay at its Nigg yard in Easter Ross....
Paul Shane, the actor famous for starring in the 1980s BBC sitcom Hi-de-Hi!, has died, his agent has confirmed....
George Hamilton shakes his head when asked if the police are hoping to broker an agreement to prevent violence during the marching season....