Nick Clegg sceptical on Lords reform referendum
Published: 19th Apr 2012 14:50:28
A referendum on whether to elect members of the House of Lords would be unnecessary and expensive, Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has said.
A parliamentary committee is expected to call for a referendum before the changes can be introduced, when it reports on the subject next week.
Mr Clegg said it would "have to work hard" to convince him one was needed.
He noted that the three biggest parties in Westminster had all had Lords reform plans in their latest manifestos.
Testifying at a separate Commons committee on Thursday, he said a referendum would cost "millions of pounds".
He told the political and constitutional reform committee: "I think the onus should be on people who want to tie up the public in terms of expense and time in a referendum on something where all the political parties agree - say they agree - and where the public basically thinks a smidgen of democracy is a fairly good idea."
Mr Clegg contrasted the calls for a referendum on Lords reform with his own decision to push for a referendum on changing the voting system used to elect MPs to the Commons.
The Liberal Democrats had wanted to move from first past the post to the alternative vote (AV), but the policy was resoundingly rejected in a public poll in May 2011.
Electing peers was different, he argued: "Unlike the referendum last year, [it] is the subject of complete consensus between the parties; we all had manifesto commitments to deliver House of Lords reform."
A number of Conservative backbenchers have objected to the Lords reform plans, threatening to block their passage through the Commons - despite the commitment of their party leadership to the proposals.
But Mr Clegg said: "When the public is asked, the public, it seems to me, just shrugs its shoulders and says, 'well of course the people who make the laws of the land should be elected by the people who have to obey the laws of the land'."
For these reasons, he said, the draft House of Lords Reform Bill committee "would have to work hard to make the case that the public should be asked to spend millions of pounds on a referendum".
But he agreed to consider next week's report by the committee of MPs and peers carefully.
In a separate development, former Labour minister Lord Adonis has renewed calls for the House of Lords to be moved out of the capital city.
"London is New York, Washington and LA rolled into one, which is unhealthy for our national politics" he argued in a letter to the Spectator.
"If the House of Lords is going to be reformed next year, part of the reform should be to move it out of London to a city in the Midlands or the north, perhaps next to the relocated BBC in MediaCity in Salford Quays," the peer continued.
He first mooted such a move in 2007, when he was a junior education minister under Tony Blair - although he stressed at the time the idea was not official government policy.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Nick Clegg sceptical on Lords reform referendum. [Online] (Updated 19 Apr 2012)
Available at: http://www.manchesterwired.co.uk/news.php/1423396-Nick-Clegg-sceptical-on-Lords-reform-referendum [Accessed 13th June 2013]
At 10:31:38 in OtherThe Archbishop of York has said he is "shocked" by warnings that one of three museums in the north of England will close if fundin...
At 09:38:35 in OtherRescuers have urged walkers to plan properly after a group of nine had to be rescued from a ridge on Snowdon....
At 06:00:53 in OtherA £362,000 extension to a Manchester skate park has been unveiled....
At 05:56:02 in OtherPatients at a Manchester hospital are to become the first in the country to be able to pick their consultant based on their previous results...
At 00:22:01 in OtherPeople in Scotland may be spending thousands of pounds on nursing home care when the NHS should be footing the bill. ...
At 20:31:08 in OtherA £90m plan to redevelop Macclesfield town centre has been approved by Cheshire East Council....
At 20:07:04 in OtherProposals to close Manchester's science museum would be a criminal, its former chair told a House of Lords debate....
At 17:55:31 in OtherThe Communication Workers Union (CWU) has claimed a further 400 call centre staff at O2 are to be made redundant following moves by the comp...
At 17:48:14 in OtherBlackpool's MPs have criticised Network Rail's block on trains running from London to the resort....
At 17:05:49 in OtherLife with non-convulsive epilepsy can be a challenge. Helen Purves recalls some of the more unusual and even dangerous things she's don...
News In Other Categories
At least 93,000 people have been killed in Syria since the start of the conflict, according to latest United Nations figures....
The Duchess of Cambridge is to officially name a new cruise ship in her last solo public engagement before she is due to give birth in July....
At least one out of every six children in the UK lives in relative poverty, according to data released by the Department for Work and Pensio...
Flying cars are yet to take off - could bikes have a better chance? ...
A former NHS employee has been arrested as part of Operation Elveden, Scotland Yard's investigation into alleged inappropriate payments...
Sports network ESPN is to close its 3D channel in the US because of a lack of uptake....