Breast cancer rules rewritten in 'landmark' study
Published: 18th Apr 2012 18:00:22
What we currently call breast cancer should be thought of as 10 completely separate diseases, according to an international study which has been described as a "landmark".
The categories could improve treatment by tailoring drugs for a patient's exact type of breast cancer and help predict survival more accurately.
The study in Nature analysed breast cancers from 2,000 women.
It will take at least three years for the findings to be used in hospitals.
Researchers compared breast cancer to a map of the world. They said tests currently used in hospitals were quite broad, splitting breast cancer up into the equivalent of continents.
The latest findings give the breast cancer map far more detail, allowing you to find individual "countries".
"Breast cancer is not one disease, but 10 different diseases," said lead researcher Prof Carlos Caldas.
The potential here is huge and it could have a transformative role in breast cancer care. However, we are a long way from using the new definitions in hospitals and the immediate impact on patients will be limited.
There are clear survival differences among the 10 categories. Clusters two and five seem to have a 15-year survival of around 40%. Clusters three and four have around 75% survival over the same period. This could help better inform patients.
In terms of treatments, there is bad news. There is a targeted therapy for just one of the 10 breast cancers groups. That is Herceptin, which is already used in a targeted group of patients. Other groups will still have "standard" therapies such as chemotherapy or radiotherapy.
The hope is that by identifying the 10 breast cancers it will be possible for researchers to design drugs for each one, but that is still a work in progress.
He added: "Our results will pave the way for doctors in the future to diagnose the type of breast cancer a woman has, the types of drugs that will work and those that won't, in a much more precise way than is currently possible."
At the moment, breast cancers are classified by what they look like under the microscope and tests for "markers" on the tumours.
Those with "oestrogen receptors" should respond to hormone therapies such as tamoxifen; those with a "Her2 receptor" can be treated with Herceptin.
The vast majority of breast cancers, more than 70%, should respond to hormone therapies. However, their reaction to treatment varies wildly. Prof Caldas said: "Some do well, some do horribly. Clearly we need better classification."
His team looked at frozen breast cancer samples from 2,000 women at hospitals in the UK and Canada.
They looked in huge detail at the genetics of the tumour cells - which genes had been mutated, which genes were working in overdrive, which were being shut down.
The study, by researchers in the UK and Canada, showed that all the different ways the cells changed when they became cancerous could be grouped into 10 different categories - named IntClust one to 10.
Prof Caldas said this was a "completely new way of looking at breast cancer".
The study was funded by Cancer Research UK. Its chief executive, Dr Harpal Kumar, said: "This is the largest ever study looking in detail at the genetics of breast tumours.
This is one of the prime examples of what could be a revolution in healthcare - "personalised medicine".
Cancers tend to be named after the place you find them; breast, colon, prostate, lung - the list goes on. It has long been known that this is not good enough, that some breast cancers can have more in common with an ovarian cancer than another breast tumour.
This study shows we should be thinking of breast cancer as 10 different diseases. Genes are going haywire in broadly 10 different ways and each category of mistake would require a different treatment.
This is the essence of personalised medicine - tailoring treatments to the genetics of a disease.
Similar studies could break other cancers down into several separate diseases, but the effects of personalised medicine could be much wider.
There are investigations into using genetic tests to predict which patients will respond well, or very badly, to blood thinners, bipolar medication and anti-HIV drugs.
The Health Secretary, Andrew Lansley, has already described the promise of the field as "immense".
There is a long way to go, as only one of the 10 breast cancer categories has a personalised treatment at the moment. But as is so often the case, breast cancer research is leading the way.
"This will change the way we look at breast cancer, it will have an enormous impact in the years to come in diagnosing and treating breast cancer.
"We think this is a landmark study."
He said the charity would begin using the new criteria in clinical trials it funded.
Outside of trials for new cancer drugs, the new breast cancer rulebook could take some time to directly benefit patients.
The researchers need to prove that the 10 classifications actually provide any benefit to people with breast cancer, before they can be used by doctors.
That process is expected to take three to five years.
The chief executive of the Breast Cancer Campaign, Baroness Delyth Morgan, said the study could "revolutionise the way breast cancer is diagnosed and treated".
"Being able to tailor treatments to the needs of individual patients is considered the Holy Grail for clinicians and this extensive study brings us another step further to that goal."
A Department of Health spokesperson said: "We are always looking at new ways to improve outcomes for cancer patients and that is why we are investing more than £750m to make sure people are diagnosed with cancer earlier and have better access to the latest treatments.
"We look forward to seeing the future results of this ongoing work and will continue to work with Cancer Research UK to find the best possible way to improve outcomes for people with breast cancer."
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Breast cancer rules rewritten in 'landmark' study. [Online] (Updated 18 Apr 2012)
Available at: http://www.manchesterwired.co.uk/news.php/1423193-Breast-cancer-rules-rewritten-in-landmark-study [Accessed 24th May 2013]
More Health News
An independent inquiry is needed into the NHS non-emergency 111 phone line "debacle" in England, GPs say....
Over 60,000 measles vaccinations have now been given which will help to reduce the length and severity of the outbreak in Swansea and Powys,...
Too often we think of NHS services in isolation....
A way of creating more effective vaccines which could protect against a broad range of flu viruses has been reported by US researchers....
Family doctors are not prepared to shore up an emergency healthcare system left unsafe by "political meddling", a GP leader is to ...
The state of NHS community nursing in England is "lamentable", nursing leaders say....
US officials are investigating the safety of caffeine in snacks and energy drinks, worried about the "cumulative impact" of the st...
We all have nearly 200 different types of fungi colonising our feet, scientists have discovered....
Two people with mental health problems have won a legal challenge against the government tests for sickness benefit. ...
The Royal Glamorgan hospital in Llantrisant could stop treating the most serious accident and emergency cases as part of a major NHS shake-u...
At 22:07:45 in OtherThe jury in the Norman Moffatt murder trial has been told to disregard the evidence of a prosecution witness. ...
At 19:57:30 in OtherA woman who stabbed her ex-boyfriend to death has been jailed for nine years after being convicted of manslaughter....
At 19:47:36 in OtherThe soldier killed in an attack in London has been named as Drummer Lee Rigby of the 2nd Battalion the Royal Regiment of Fusiliers....
At 18:48:37 in OtherDrummer Lee Rigby - the soldier killed close to Woolwich Barracks, in south-east London - was "a bubbly character" and "lovin...
At 18:32:24 in OtherA man has been charged with murder following the stabbing of a 37-year-old man in Liverpool. ...
At 14:40:56 in OtherAn independent inquiry is needed into the NHS non-emergency 111 phone line "debacle" in England, GPs say....
At 14:12:39 in OtherWhat has been described as Scotland's first purpose-built cycling track for disabled people has been opened by Paralympic cyclist Karen...
At 12:29:16 in OtherWith news that Premier League attendances have increased by nearly 4% since last season and champions Manchester United average 75,529 fans ...
At 12:28:28 in HeadlinesA Bangladesh government report into the collapse of a multi-storey factory building, which killed more than 1,100, has uncovered a series of...
At 08:08:26 in OtherAn extension to the Metrolink system in Greater Manchester has opened to passengers three months early. ...
News In Other Categories
Robert Redford has received a standing ovation for his performance in All Is Lost at the film's Cannes premiere. ...
A radio that is able to change a broadcast depending on where you are and what you are doing has been demonstrated by the BBC....
A steep decline in foreign students coming to study at UK colleges and language schools has prompted fears of a knock-on effect on universit...
Chinese scientists have acquired new insights into how white tigers get their colouration....
The soldier killed in an attack in London has been named as Drummer Lee Rigby of the 2nd Battalion the Royal Regiment of Fusiliers....
A man has been charged over allegations racist tweets were sent to two football players....