Breast cancer screens leads to 'unnecessary treatment'
Published: 3rd Apr 2012 02:09:55
Up to one-in-four breast cancers detected by screening would never have gone on to be fatal or cause any symptoms, US researchers say.
Their study based on 39,888 women in Norway said between 15% and 25% of breast cancers were "overdiagnosed".
They said this led to unnecessary treatment such as surgery, chemotherapy or radiotherapy.
In England, the evidence for screening is being reviewed amid controversy about the measure's effectiveness.
Health bodies around the world work on the principle that breast cancer screening saves lives. However, some researchers have argued that it may cause more harm than good.
A review of clinical trials involving a total of 600,000 women concluded it was "not clear whether screening does more good than harm".
Academics at Harvard School of Public Health looked at nearly 40,000 cases of breast cancer in Norway. They took advantage of a natural experiment to determine the effect of screening as different regions in Norway introduced screening at different times between 1996 and 2005.
The findings, presented in Annals of Public Health, showed 15% and 25% of breast cancers were "overdiagnosed" by screening.
This worked out at preventing one death for every 2,500 women screened, but six to 10 cases of overdiagnosis.
One of the researchers, Dr Mette Kalager, said: "Mammography might not be appropriate for use in breast-cancer screening because it cannot distinguish between progressive and non-progressive cancer.
"Radiologists have been trained to find even the smallest of tumours in a bid to detect as many cancers as possible to be able to cure breast cancer.
"However, the present study adds to the increasing body of evidence that this practice has caused a problem for women - diagnosis of breast cancer that wouldn't cause symptoms or death."
The national cancer director for England, Prof Mike Richards, has announced a review into breast cancer screening.
Dr Julie Sharp, Cancer Research UK's senior science information manager, said: "Cancer Research UK is working with the National Cancer Director on an independent review of breast screening.
"Women need more accurate, evidence-based and clear information to be able to make an informed choice about breast screening. The decision whether to be screened is a personal one and that decision should be made with all of the potential harms and benefits fully explained.
"Until we have the results of the review, Cancer Research UK's position is that we remain supportive of breast screening."
Dr Caitlin Palframan, policy manager at Breakthrough Breast Cancer, said: "The rate of overdiagnosis in breast cancer screening has been debated widely and led to confusing messages for women on the effectiveness of breast screening.
"However, we believe that screening is vital as it helps detect breast cancer early when treatment options are likely to be less aggressive and have more successful outcomes."
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Breast cancer screens leads to 'unnecessary treatment'. [Online] (Updated 03 Apr 2012)
Available at: http://www.manchesterwired.co.uk/news.php/1420274-Breast-cancer-screens-leads-to-unnecessary-treatment [Accessed 13th May 2013]
At 18:15:23 in OtherBangladesh has set up a panel to raise the minimum wage for more than three million garment workers, the minister for textiles has said....
At 11:52:59 in OtherOne of Britain's most wanted fugitives has been arrested on Spain's Costa Blanca....
At 10:50:47 in OtherA 17-year-old boy is fighting for his life after being attacked in Manchester city centre, police have said....
At 10:05:34 in OtherA man has been charged with escaping lawful custody after two people were allegedly sprung from a prison van....
At 00:05:36 in OtherStars from the world of TV are preparing for this year's Bafta Awards, with Olympic satire Twenty Twelve and BBC drama Accused among th...
At 10:45:43 in OtherA sheep once sold for slaughter is looking for a new home after turning up on a couple's patio. ...
At 09:33:20 in OtherThousands of football fans from Greater Manchester are making their way to London for the FA Cup final....
At 01:13:49 in OtherA memorial marking the 28th anniversary of the Bradford City football stadium fire, in which 56 people died, is to take place later....
At 21:50:33 in OtherEight people have been arrested in Northern Ireland within the last 24 hours by immigration enforcement officers from the Home Office....
At 19:06:48 in OtherThe second of two men being hunted by police after a prison van escape on 30 April has been recaptured, Greater Manchester Police have said....
News In Other Categories
A 15-year-old boy has been charged over an acid attack on a woman in Romford, east London....
More than half of common plant species and a third of animals could see a serious decline in their habitat range because of climate change....
Jazz and pop singer Caro Emerald's second album, The Shocking Miss Emerald, has shot to the top of the charts, pushing East London dru...
Foreign visitors to North Korea are allowed to attend sports matches alongside their minders. But football in this secretive republic has li...
The introduction of energy smart meters in 30 million UK homes will be delayed for more than a year, the government has announced....
Twelve people have been shot during a Mother's Day parade in the US city of New Orleans, police say....